Discussion about this post

User's avatar
drsmithy's avatar

While I agree the “gender pay gap” is misrepresented by averaging across the entire workforce, I think your argument is specious because a substantial fraction of people are not operating in a “household” for a substantial fraction of their lives (and quite frankly it shouldn't matter, nobody is making salary decisions based on whether or not they're in a "household").

Typical (first) marriage age is about 30.

Something like 20% of households are not couples.

Something like 50% of marriages end in divorce.

And while averaging across the whole workforce does make the gender pay gap looks worse than it actually is, it also raises the question of why are low-paying jobs dominated by women, and why even in those industries, are the vast majority of higher-paying roles held by men.

For a personal anecdote, a while back ago my wife received a significant (over $25k) pay rise as a result of a salary review, to bring her salary in-line with the other - all male - members of her team (all of whom received very small, barely-inflation bumps), along with a once-off bonus intended to be back-pay for previous years. She is an Electrical Engineer in her 40s. The (department wide) salary review was instituted by the new, female, department head.

This was certainly not the first time in her ~20 year career a non-trivial pay discrepancy had existed between her and her male peers, but it _was_ the first time it was pro-actively addressed.

I do think that much of the real “gender pay gap” (ie: controlling for similar jobs) would be fixed by legislating wage transparency (ie: force employers to publish job titles and salary ranges, along with anonymised data of what they’re actually paying). The relative unwillingness of women to negotiate salary is well documented.

Expand full comment
The Emergent City's avatar

On a similar topic, I’d like to see some research done on how much of the retail market is geared towards women’s spending which could shed some light on the informal economy / discretionary spending you are talking about.

Anecdotally, when I walk around a Westfield, it seems like maybe 8/10 shops are expressly intended for women.

I personally spend almost nothing in my household except for food, public transport and the occasional bottle of whisky. My wife however has every dollar I’ll ever earn for the rest of my life already allocated 🤣

Expand full comment
31 more comments...

No posts